CX's & O's: The ESG Pendulum Swings Back

Just a few years ago, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives were at the forefront of corporate strategy. Companies scrambled to outdo one another with bold sustainability commitments, ambitious DEI programs, and governance reforms. Investors rewarded ESG-driven businesses, and consumers—particularly younger generations—expected brands to take strong ethical stances.

But today, the pendulum is swinging back.

Corporate commitments that once seemed untouchable are now under scrutiny. Governments are dialing back regulations, activist investors are questioning ESG’s impact on returns, and some consumers are pushing back against perceived corporate overreach. The once-unified momentum around ESG is now fragmented, leaving many brands in an awkward position:

• Do we double down on ESG, even as the landscape shifts?

• Do we pull back to avoid potential backlash?

• How do we continue to differentiate when ESG is no longer the automatic brand advantage it once was?

The truth is, ESG isn’t disappearing—it’s just evolving. And in uncertain times, the brands that stand out are the ones that adapt to the new reality without abandoning their core values.

1. ESG Fatigue Meets Economic Pressure

One reason for the shift? Fatigue.

In the rush to embrace ESG, some companies overpromised and underdelivered. Lofty “net zero” commitments lacked clear roadmaps. DEI pledges felt more like public relations efforts than genuine culture shifts. And as inflation and economic pressures mounted, businesses started prioritizing survival over sustainability.

A recent study found that investor enthusiasm for ESG-focused funds is cooling, with performance concerns outweighing ethical considerations. Some firms are even rebranding their sustainability initiatives under new labels like “responsible business” or “long-term value creation” to avoid political and investor scrutiny.

In short, the ESG gold rush is over—and only those with substance behind their commitments will retain credibility.

2. Greenwashing Is No Longer an Option

For years, companies have talked a big ESG game without doing the work. Now, consumers and regulators are pushing back hard against greenwashing, virtue signaling, and performative activism.

Consider the recent EU crackdown on misleading environmental claims—companies now need scientific proof to back up sustainability marketing. In the U.S., ESG-related lawsuits are rising, targeting companies accused of making exaggerated claims.

The message is clear: Saying you’re ESG-focused is no longer enough. You have to prove it.

Brands that want to stand out must shift from big, sweeping commitments to real, measurable progress. That means:

✅ Transparency over perfection – Admit where you are in the process and provide clear, verifiable metrics.
✅ Proof over promises – Third-party audits, certifications, and impact reports matter more than aspirational targets.
✅ Action over activism – Move beyond “corporate statements” and embed ESG into the business model itself.

3. The Opportunity: A More Pragmatic ESG

While some companies scale back their ESG focus, others have an opportunity to stand out by being smarter about it. The next wave of ESG leadership won’t come from the loudest voices—it will come from brands that integrate sustainability, social responsibility, and governance into their operations in practical, profitable ways.

What does that look like?

🔹 Sustainability as a cost-saver, not a cost center – Brands that position sustainability as an efficiency play (e.g., reducing waste, lowering energy costs) will win support even from ESG skeptics.

🔹 Workforce-first social impact – Instead of vague social initiatives, smart companies will focus on workplace culture, fair wages, and career development, which have tangible ROI in employee retention and engagement.

🔹 Risk-based governance – Investors still care about ESG—but they now want proof that it mitigates long-term risk rather than just serving as a branding exercise.

4. Standing Out in an ESG Backlash Era

With the ESG pendulum swinging backwards, brands have two choices: react cautiously or adapt boldly. The companies that stay the course—but do so differently—will stand out the most.

🔸 Be specific, not broad – Instead of vague sustainability goals, focus on one or two high-impact areas where you can truly lead.
🔸 Tie ESG to business performance – Make it clear how your ESG initiatives drive cost savings, efficiency, or customer loyalty.
🔸 Keep moving forward, but with evidence – The strongest brands will keep ESG at the core of their business, but not as a marketing slogan—as a competitive advantage.

Putting It All Together

We are entering a new phase of ESG—one where bold statements no longer cut it, scrutiny is higher than ever, and companies must prove that their commitments create real value.

For brands that take a pragmatic, results-driven approach, this is an opportunity to differentiate in a sea of retreating competitors.

Because while the ESG pendulum may be swinging back, one thing remains true: the brands that endure are the ones that adapt—without losing what makes them stand out.

Thanks for reading and see you here next week!

Sincerely,
Louis

PS - Welcome to everyone who joined CX’s & O’s last week! Let’s keep the conversation going. Connect with me on Linkedin for daily tips and insights!

PPS - If you like these insights, check out my new book “One to One: How to Wow Your Customers With Personalized Experiences.” Learn more.